This report currently available on the Welsh Parliament website, warns governments to take heed of the French experience where many areas of France are now uninstalling WIMAX systems, acknowledging them as an expensive “technological error” and facing class-action suit against the regional government of Burgundy with regard to the adverse health effects experienced subsequent to the roll-out of WIMAX in the region.

“High speed internet connectivity via WiFi and WIMAX is inferior in several ways to a wired − especially a fibre-optic − connection:
Connectivity is unreliable…
WIMAX and WiFi will shortly become obsolete technologies. The implementation of WIMAX would therefore represent an irresponsible waste of public money. Wales should invest for the long-term rather than for the short-term (a fibre-optic network would be permanent, much like that of the utilities).
….
Having installed WIMAX systems, many areas of France are now replacing them with wired systems, acknowledging that WIMAX was a “technological error” (Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur, Somme, Artois, Creuse, Aveyron), while other areas of France have decided to pursue a wired-only solution (Auvergne, Oise, Gironde).

Alain Paulien, a manager with France Telecom, recently condemned WIMAX as an expensive waste of public money.

In November 2006 a group of German doctors signed an open letter to Chancellor Angela Merkel asking for WIMAX not to be implemented on health grounds, and in September 2007 the German government warned its citizens to avoid using WiFi.

It should be underlined that technologies using this form of pulsed microwaves have never been pre-market tested for safety and have only been in wide use for the past 10-15 years. The latency period for carcinogenic outcomes may be 20 years or more.

Any system based on wireless digital communications systems must be avoided for rural Wales – and anywhere else for that matter.

The correct solution is fibre-optic technology which is reliable, fast and perfectly safe.”

http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201012/cmselect/cmwelaf/writev/broadband/bb01.htm

UK Parliament: Broadband in Wales

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *